Math, Beauty, and Ego

A.T., Undergraduate mathematics student in the United Kingdom

Mathematics is beautiful. Definitions expose just the right level of detail and structure, and then, through a chain of immaculate deduction, we are led from propositions and lemmas to the pièce de résistance: the theorem. In just three years of undergraduate study, I’ve been fortunate enough to encounter many examples of this: Gauss’s Theorema Egregium, the classification of covering spaces, and the central limit theorem, to name a few. But beyond the formal chain of deduction lies something more profound. Mathematics is an art full of elegance, surprise, and inevitability.

I am in good company. Hardy, in A Mathematician’s Apology, writes that “beauty is the first test: there is no permanent place in the world for ugly mathematics”.1 Poincaré goes further: the scientist “takes pleasure in it because it is beautiful”.2 And Russell saw in mathematics the combination of “godlike freedom, with the sense of inevitable destiny”.3

Over the course of my undergraduate degree, AI progress in mathematics has been remarkable. When ChatGPT first appeared in November 2022, there was a striking asymmetry between its dexterity with words and its capability at mathematics.4 A model that could produce fluent prose could fail at basic arithmetic.5 At the time, it felt almost blindingly obvious that a machine would never understand the intricate structure and logic of mathematics.

Progress did not care what we thought. In 2024, Google DeepMind announced AlphaGeometry, which solved 25 of 30 Olympiad geometry problems.6 In 2025, Gemini Deep Think reached gold-medal standard at the International Mathematical Olympiad (IMO).7

Surely, we thought, models would plateau: IMO problems were still not real problems. Then came the slew of Erdős problems8 —still, we said, not real math. The Jacobian conjecture, open for 87 years, fell to Anthropic’s Claude Fable 5.9 It was announced almost casually, in a tweet. That captured the absurdity of the last two years: progress had been so fast that results that would once have felt like science fiction barely moved us at all. Somewhere along the way, an inversion happened: first I was much smarter than the models; now they were much smarter than I.

On September 8, 2026, came the final, shattering blow: OpenAI announced that an internal model had produced a paper claiming to resolve the Navier–Stokes smoothness and existence problem: in an incompressible fluid under a smooth external force, a blow-up existed in finite time.10 Despite having seen rumours circulating the previous day11, this came as a huge shock. I remember, unable to think very much at all, taking the train to Kamakura and running along the coastline in the rain—I just wanted to get away from it all.

But mathematics remained beautiful. Gauss’s Theorema Egregium, the classification of covering spaces, and the central limit theorem had not changed because OpenAI had resolved Navier–Stokes. So why was I grieving? Was it not absurd that the proof of a single theorem made me want to run away from it all?

I wrote to an older professor, an expert in harmonic analysis whose work concerns the Navier–Stokes equations, about my worries. I told him that I grieved to see our art being taken over by machines and behemoth AI companies looking for their next marketing stunt. Greater still was the loss of identity: the skill I had spent years cultivating was suddenly no longer rare, and perhaps no longer valuable either.

His reply contained a thought that struck me deeply. “Beautiful things, poetry or Mathematics, remain beautiful even though machines can copy us in uncanny ways. Contemplation of beauty is always marvellous,” he wrote, “but most of us would not be content with pure contemplation.”

Why, though, are we not content with pure contemplation?

And here, I feel, lies the ugly truth about mathematics, and one that I refused to recognise for so long: mathematics is as much about ego, pride, and ambition as it is about beauty.

Even in my own case, my reasons for starting mathematics were far from a monastic pursuit of beauty. I was good at it, and I loved being good at it. At school, there was nothing quite like the exhilaration of doing well in math competitions and math Olympiads: math, hard math, was something that I was not just good at—but much better at than others. It flattered my ego.

I am hardly alone in this. Hardy made a similar reflection, writing that his motives for doing mathematics were “far from noble”: “I wanted to beat other boys, and this seemed to be the way in which I could do so most decisively”.12 John Conway, upon discovering the surreal numbers, described spending six weeks thinking not only how beautiful the mathematics was but “how clever you are, John, to have discovered it”.13 And Timothy Gowers, in a recent blog post, wrote that his “main motivation for becoming a mathematician was the dream that I would solve unsolved problems—the more famous the better”; perhaps, he wondered, solving problems had simply been a way of “getting respect from a small group of peers.”14

AI begins to separate these two aspects of mathematics. For most of its history, beauty and achievement were intertwined: great mathematical work was both an encounter with something beautiful and the culmination of the mathematician’s own ambition, effort, and creativity. AI threatens the latter far more than the former.

I found this thought deeply reassuring. One day soon, machines may surpass us in all manner of intellectual tasks. But one thing they can never take away from us is our capacity to contemplate beauty—not just in math, but in music, literature, and more—nor our capacity to fall deeply into thought. Mathematics does not become less beautiful because machines are better at it than us.

And yet there is something unsatisfying about this reassurance. It is too simplistic to label all that is threatened here “ego”. We want to do more than just gaze at mathematical beauty. We want to take part in this grand game ourselves: to struggle through hard problems, spend months or years in deep thought, and leave our mark on this centuries-long human endeavour. To be human is to want to achieve great things, and this is much more than ego, hubris, or vanity.

In my reply, I told the professor that if I had the humility to let go of my ego, what I loved most about mathematics remained intact.

A few days later, he wrote back. He agreed that there was truth in what I said, but added one final qualification:

“We might be called to let go of our ego, but there is a thin line between ambition (in its positive meaning) and pride (in its negative meaning).”


Received 2 November 2026.

  1. Hardy, A Mathematician’s Apology, §10. ↩︎
  2. Poincaré, Science and Method, p. 22. ↩︎
  3. Russell, letter to Gilbert Murray. ↩︎
  4. OpenAI, ChatGPT announcement. ↩︎
  5. Yuan et al., ChatGPT and arithmetic. ↩︎
  6. Google DeepMind, AlphaGeometry. ↩︎
  7. Google DeepMind, Gemini at the IMO. ↩︎
  8. Feng et al., Gemini and Erdős problems. ↩︎
  9. Alpöge, Jacobian counterexample announcement. ↩︎
  10. OpenAI, Navier–Stokes announcement. ↩︎
  11. Buckmaster, statement on the Navier–Stokes developments. ↩︎
  12. Hardy, A Mathematician’s Apology, §29. ↩︎
  13. Conway, interview on surreal numbers. ↩︎
  14. Gowers, on the Fields medallists’ letter. ↩︎
More by →

14 responses to “Math, Beauty, and Ego”

  1. Scott Guthery Avatar
    Scott Guthery

    See Sabine Hossenfelder, Lost in Math: How Beauty Leads Physics Astray. If you want to do mathematics solely for beauty’s sake, maybe we should move the department of mathematics to the School of Fine Arts.

    1. Fred Daum Avatar
      Fred Daum

      Dirac and Einstein and Maxwell and many other great physicists thought that beauty is a powerful heuristic. Hossenfelder’s complaint is specifically about string theory, which so far has not worked out in physics, but which has stimulated much interesting new math to wrestle with.

    2. Anonymous Avatar
      Anonymous

      The department of mathematics is not the department of physics, nor is it beholden to what physicists deem worth studying.

      Moreover, I would not take Sabine Hossenfelder as an authority on any subject other than Youtube clickbait.

  2. Gabriel Avatar
    Gabriel

    No one will pay you to “contemplate beauty” — not to mention that mathematical activity in practice is hardly “contemplative”. Mathematicians don’t spend their working days staring at theorems with teary eyes. Most of the time, it is all about the struggle to find a strategy, the false starts, the new concepts that may or may not lead to a proof. With AI, much of it is gone.

    1. Fred Daum Avatar
      Fred Daum

      With AI the struggle is pushed to a higher level. We can now tackle problems that we thought were out of reach using only human brains. We are now free of the drudgery of mindless symbol manipulation, which the computer does much faster now. We can invent new problems to wrestle with, rather than being stuck with the boring old Millennium problems or Hilbert’s problems or Smale’s problems. There are plenty of new interesting math problems undreamt of in our philosophy. These problems are waiting for us to dream them up.

    2. Sal Avatar
      Sal

      I don’t spend my days “staring at theorems with teary eyes” but I certainly spend a lot of time thinking about mathematical structures (ones both related to my work and others not so much). Is this not being contemplative?

      1. Gabriel Avatar
        Gabriel

        “Contemplation” is correlated with a passive attittude toward the target of contemplation. When I look at a painting or at the mountais that extend infinitely on the horizon, there is no particular “thought” involved, or intellectual effort. When you think about mathematical structures, on the other hand, you make a concerted effort to understand it, or to use it in order to understand another structure. At the end, you may get to a “contemplative state” where you delight yourself on the beauty of the final result, but that’s a small part of the entire enterprise. I hear many mathematicians make claims about “beauty” as this is all that math is all about, but there is a substantial disconnect between their perception and what actually goes on on their daily activity — or even on what really matters for them. There is a very natural, human tendency to romanticize our own lives. It’s understandable, but reality usually disagrees.

        1. Sal Avatar
          Sal

          Cambridge dictionary entry on contemplation: “serious and quiet thought for a period of time” I fail to see why it would be disjoint from “intellectual effort”.

          1. Gabriel Avatar
            Gabriel

            If “contemplating X” is simply synonimous to “thinking about X”, then obviously there is no point in discussing this. But that’s not the only meaning of the word, and it doesn’t seem to me that that was the meaning used in the post.

  3. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    The people working at BigAI will not reflect on their own egos. They’ll tell other people to surrender their egos.

    “The meek shall inherit the earth, but not its mineral rights.”

  4. Johnny Avatar
    Johnny

    It’s a beautiful take. I count myself among the mathematicians who fell in love with mathematics not because they wanted to compete or be smarter than others, but simply because they found it fun and interesting. I’m sure most of us don’t love the academic system. I didn’t know anything about papers or conjectures, but I knew I wanted to do maths.

    However, I’m not sure taxpayers would be happy to pay people to simply “contemplate”—and understandably so.

    1. Anonymous Avatar
      Anonymous

      I think they don’t pay you specifically for proving theorems either. They pay to keep the expertise alive, and proving theorems is one part of it.

      Imagine a world where all math is done at OpenAI or at the site with the ominous name math.inc. Then one AI makes a study that falsifies statistics and says smoking is healthy and another AI approves it. If the public has defunded all mathematicians everyone must believe the machine gods.

      If Optimus robots can go through physical archives, will historians say they should be defunded because OpenAI can write all history now?

      So yes, maybe don’t use “contemplate” in a pitch to politicians (though in some EU countries you could), but I think this article wasn’t a pitch.

  5. John Mitchell Avatar
    John Mitchell

    The divergent attitudes toward intelligent machines we see in current discussions were on display decades ago, interestingly enough.

    Alan Turing foresaw that human vanity would be a source of dread at the thought of intelligent machines:

    “We like to believe that Man is in some subtle way superior to the rest of creation. … [This feeling] is likely to be quite strong in intellectual people, since they value the power of thinking more highly than others, and are more inclined to base their belief in the superiority of Man on this power.” (1) He seemed to be mockingly dismissive of this attitude.

    Ted Kaczynski (*) embodied the sense of dread that Turing mocked, but I think his description of what motivates scientists (in part) applies to mathematicians as well:

    “to have a goal (a scientific problem to solve), to make an effort (research) and to attain the goal (solution of the problem.) … [S]cientists work mainly for the fulfillment they get out of the work itself. … Other motives do play a role for many scientists. Money and status for example.”

    Kaczynski’s views on social control of technological progress seem very relevant nowadays:

    “Thus science marches on blindly, without regard to the real welfare of the human race or to any other standard, obedient only to the psychological needs of the scientists and of the government officials and corporation executives who provide the funds for research.” (2)

    (*) My comments on Kaczynski are not meant to condone the use of violence; I separate his analysis and prognosis from the methods he used to get his warnings published.

    [1] Alan Turing, “Computing Machinery and Intelligence”, Mind, 1950

    [2] Ted Kaczynski, “Industrial Society and its Future”, 1995

Comments are moderated. Read our comment policy.

Add to the discussion

New posts by email.

Prefer a feed reader? Subscribe by RSS.

Also on Mathstodon.

Latest comments across the site.

  1. The divergent attitudes toward intelligent machines we see in current discussions were on display decades ago, interestingly enough. Alan Turing...

  2. Minor correction to the part from the Gita (with some help from my ChatGPT):Arjuna already knew that Krishna was divine,...