A mathematical community?

Jean-Michel Kantor, Emeritus from IMJ (Institut Mathématique de Jussieu), mathematician and historian of mathematics

In reply to Slow Maths by Isabelle Gallagher

This is an answer to Isabelle Gallagher, President of SMF (Société Mathématique de France).

Her proposals are based on two assumptions which are worth a debate:

1. The notion of “mathematical community”

Recent events and publishing materials coming from various countries and continents, in particular from USA and Europe, show that a world mathematical community does not exist and that – if it ever existed – is in the process of disruption.

For example the proposals of Sergiu Klainerman1 and the practice of American mathematicians, involving gigantic amounts of dollars invested in AI-laboratories, reflect the local practices of a supposed “American mathematical community” without mentioning any community outside of Silicon Valley and/or Princeton.

2. Science and technique

Mathematics is confronted not to a scientific debate involving the mathematical practice but to an imposed debate involving a technology, submitted to different laws, in particular, as was expressed by Dennis Gabor (1900–1979, physicist, Nobel Prize in 1971 for the invention of holography) with Gabor’s law:

“What can be done technically will necessarily be done, sooner or later.”2

Applied to AI, juiced up with billions of dollars of the economico-political US domination (till when?) – a dimension surprisingly never mentioned in comments from our American mathematician colleagues.

  1. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2610.29713 ↩︎
  2. « Ce qui peut être fait techniquement sera fait nécessairement ». Also stated by Jacques Ellul in France. ↩︎

Received 6 November 2026.

More by →

4 responses to “A mathematical community?”

  1. FN Avatar
    FN

    No need to add more…technique obeys its own logic. Too bad for traditional math academia being wiped out by AI. But according to some tech insiders, it will soon be the least of our worries

    https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/22/magazine/looking-for-the-formula-to-stop-an-apocalypse.html

  2. Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote Avatar
    Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote

    Indeed, when we read “the mathematical community”, what is meant is “the Ivy League mathematical community”. The rest of the world will be (as usual) colonized, captured and wiped out.

  3. Michael Rozynski Avatar
    Michael Rozynski

    “Applied to AI, juiced up with billions of dollars of the economico-political US domination”

    AI = ‘Abject Intimidation’ or ‘Arrogant Indifference’

  4. billjr Avatar
    billjr

    I agree that it’s an imposed debate, but I’m a little unclear on what you would like the American community to do (other than try to make compute available as broadly as possible, which I agree with). Should people resist asking Claude whether RH is true? Resist posting the Lean code, if it says that is? Curiousity is the most fundamental characteristic of any mathematician, and it’s simply not human to expect people not to discuss what they find.

Comments are moderated. Read our comment policy.

Add to the discussion

New posts by email.

Prefer a feed reader? Subscribe by RSS.

Also on Mathstodon.

Latest comments across the site.

  1. I agree that it’s an imposed debate, but I’m a little unclear on what you would like the American community...

  2. “Don’t work on another individual or group’s tasks, especially using AI, without asking them first.” Yes. These guidelines are much...

  3. The title has a strange similarity with “Letter to an young poet” by RM Rilke, if that seem relevant