This is an answer to Isabelle Gallagher, President of SMF (Société Mathématique de France).
Her proposals are based on two assumptions which are worth a debate:
1. The notion of “mathematical community”
Recent events and publishing materials coming from various countries and continents, in particular from USA and Europe, show that a world mathematical community does not exist and that – if it ever existed – is in the process of disruption.
For example the proposals of Sergiu Klainerman1 and the practice of American mathematicians, involving gigantic amounts of dollars invested in AI-laboratories, reflect the local practices of a supposed “American mathematical community” without mentioning any community outside of Silicon Valley and/or Princeton.
2. Science and technique
Mathematics is confronted not to a scientific debate involving the mathematical practice but to an imposed debate involving a technology, submitted to different laws, in particular, as was expressed by Dennis Gabor (1900–1979, physicist, Nobel Prize in 1971 for the invention of holography) with Gabor’s law:
“What can be done technically will necessarily be done, sooner or later.”2
Applied to AI, juiced up with billions of dollars of the economico-political US domination (till when?) – a dimension surprisingly never mentioned in comments from our American mathematician colleagues.
- https://arxiv.org/pdf/2610.29713 ↩︎
- « Ce qui peut être fait techniquement sera fait nécessairement ». Also stated by Jacques Ellul in France. ↩︎
Received 6 November 2026.

Add to the discussion