What do you do with an asshole?

Aaron Stump, Professor of Computer Science at Boston College. Cross-posted at his blog.

Here’s a thought experiment. Imagine that a very senior colleague, regarded as near the top of his field, made it his business to find out what young researchers were working on, and then solve their problems. Imagine, too, that he gave no credit to them for the efforts they had made so far, and furthermore was so disrespectful as not even to publish the work, but just post it on his blog. And he does this repeatedly, despite being urged in terms both polite and strident, from many parties, to stop.

Do you know what we would call that person? An asshole.

What would we do about such a person? Well, since no laws are being broken or anything like that, we would resort to a time-honored social response: we would just shun that person. They wouldn’t get invited anywhere, no one would talk to them, etc. It could get a little ugly, if some people still wanted to be friends with that person, but, shunning is pretty serious. And behavior like that totally deserves it.


Received 30 October 2026.

More by →

16 responses to “What do you do with an asshole?”

  1. Bogdan Grechuk Avatar
    Bogdan Grechuk

    I would use asshole. I would encourage “young researchers that were working on” the problem to rewrite asshole’s solution in their way, give proper credit to all work asshole used, including their own work, and submit for publication, without including asshole as a co-author (instead, include a short asshole statement at the end of the paper acknowledging how asshole’s ideas were used). I would encourage the community to give credit to authors of such papers, not to asshole. I would encourage people to understand the most brilliant of asshole’s ideas and apply them to other problems. As a result, asshole work will be used to facilitate progress and enrich understanding.

  2. . Avatar
    .

    You forgot to pay 200USD per month

  3. John Mitchell Avatar
    John Mitchell

    To make the thought experiment a bit more faithful to the real world, imagine that people might make a lot of money by buying stock in the asshole, and that a few can make ocean liners full of money by working for the asshole.

    Not all answers to “What would you do?” are noble.

  4. Bogdan Grechuk Avatar
    Bogdan Grechuk

    “You forgot to pay 200USD per month” – Indeed, I forgot to mention that, while all proof asshole posted on his blog are of course can be read for free, he also offers a deal to work on YOUR PROBLEMS for 200USD per month. It is up to your whether to accept the deal.

    1. Sal Avatar
      Sal

      Well it is not only up to you whether the deal is accepted, anyone could accept the deal. Meaning YOUR PROBLEMS are more readily up for grabs which could stifle a potential collaboration.

  5. Una Avatar
    Una

    The asshole did this not for nothing. It’s a show off and the goal is public’s attention.

    The best way to deal with it is to withdraw your attention.

    When the asshole run out of famous problems, public will soon lose their interest to the asshole.

  6. Anon Avatar
    Anon

    The analogy likens human mathematicians to junior colleagues of the asshole.

    AI : ASSHOLE :: HUMAN MATHEMATICIAN : YOUNG RESEARCHER.

    That may be the case.

  7. Pronab Pal Avatar

    Why this note posted here -at proofsandprompts ?

  8. Scott Guthery Avatar
    Scott Guthery

    I prefer the term “thesis advisor.”

  9. Sirawit Pongnakintr Avatar
    Sirawit Pongnakintr

    Here’s a thought experiment. Imagine that a group of colleagues got some knowledge revealed while dreaming. They posted free knowledge on their blogs. People complain them.

    Do you know what I would call the people complaining them? Assholes.

    What would we do about such people? Well, since no laws are being broken or anything like that, we would resort to a time-honored social response: we would just shun those.

    1. Soda Avatar
      Soda

      You still don’t understand what’s happening.

      It’s not about math knowledge, it’s about who is going to set the agenda of math research in the future.

      You want to fully rely on AI companies? Don’t be so naive.

      1. Sirawit Pongnakintr Avatar
        Sirawit Pongnakintr

        I don’t think we’re relying on anyone. If someone smart teach me knowledge. Good! If some robots teach me knowledge. Also good!

        People will keep studying and keep researching. If someone get something new, good! If in the end no one gets anything new, since a random big robot has given a dump of knowledge, then also good!

        I don’t think we should really care “who is the most genius in the world”. Maybe previously humans. Maybe machines in the future? Let them do what they do. We can still study and research in the way we want. How can the “genius” person automatically has the power to set the agenda of math research in the future?

        1. Soda Avatar
          Soda

          Think about this: who picked those conjectures the AI companies are solving now? It’s the mathematicians, past or current.

          What if all conjectures were solved? Can AI pick the problems by itself? Then why would its problems matter to humans?

          It’s not the “genius” who sets the agenda; it must be humans who set the agenda. Then future math will still have meaning to humans.

          If AI generates “math” that we can’t understand and can’t use, then why bother to generate that “math”?

          1. Sirawit Pongnakintr Avatar
            Sirawit Pongnakintr

            If they generate by themselves and we can’t understand it, then we will be stuck trying to understand it, while we will also work on other things they don’t (i.e. education, seminars, etc). They can generate all they want, but we’re not going to keep ourselves full-time looking at it (and that’s fine)!

            I don’t think anyone will pick the agenda. Everyone will have some math to care about. They do theirs and we do ours. If we have chance to digest each other’s work then that’s good! If not, that’s also ok.

            Which way mathematics will go depends on the person doing mathematics (regardless of humans or AI). There won’t be a global “agenda” for everyone to follow.

            1. Soda Avatar
              Soda

              You don’t need to “be stuck trying to understand it”. You can just ignore them, as Aaron Stump suggested, “just shun that”.

              Life is short, don’t waste your time on something that you can’t understand and can’t use.

              Only suggestions, it’s up to you, since you are the lord of your life, same as others.

  10. Scott Guthery Avatar
    Scott Guthery

    “…set the agenda of math research…” is a telling turn of phrase. It also turned up in the Leiden Declaration on Artificial Intelligence and Mathematics. Is it any wonder that Mr. MITS starts to distrust science and its queen when he learns that they are following a hidden agenda? Perhaps someone here could describe today’s “agenda of math research,” beyond getting tenure, of course.

Comments are moderated. Read our comment policy.

Add to the discussion

New posts by email.

Prefer a feed reader? Subscribe by RSS.

Also on Mathstodon.

Latest comments across the site.

  1. You don’t need to “be stuck trying to understand it”. You can just ignore them, as Aaron Stump suggested, “just...