Update on a new type of paper mill

Eric Dolores-Cuenca, Postdoc at Yonsei University

In reply to A new type of paper mill by Eric Dolores-Cuenca

If paper mills in mathematics appear, we need to focus on what journal editors can do and how to prevent mathematicians from misbehaving. The replies to the original post include possible ideas to help journal editors.

In finance, several banks stressed their workers until the workers started to fake transactions. This led to many people being fired. Eventually, banks were forced to change their work culture.1

The math community is already struggling with its own scandal: in November 2023 Clarivate announced that it had excluded the field of mathematics from the latest edition of its list of highly cited authors. One of the reasons is that schools paid mathematicians to add them as their affiliation, even if there was no interaction with the researcher.

The International Math Union and the International Council for Industrial and Applied Mathematics created a report on the problem,2 and they also shared suggestions to prevent future fraud.3 I believe that if paper mills appear, the suggested actions will also reduce the number of mathematicians engaging in paper mill related fraud.

I hope some schools listen to those recommendations. Note that Clarivate “have paused impact evaluations since 2022 to focus on quality evaluation of submitted and indexed journals”, that they extended the Journal Impact Factor to ESCI journals, and created unified rankings.4 Even if Clarivate is asking us to focus on quality and not on the index a paper belongs to, on job applications one can still find schools that filter the candidates by only counting SCIE papers.

Just as in the finance case, a change of culture is needed if we want to prevent mathematicians from committing fraud.

Acknowledgement: I would like to thank Susana Lopez Moreno for related discussions.

  1. Wikipedia contributors, Wells Fargo cross-selling scandal, Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia (accessed 1 November 2026). ↩︎
  2. Ilka Agricola, Lynn Heller, Wil Schilders, Moritz Schubotz, Peter Taylor and Luis Vega, Fraudulent Publishing in the Mathematical Sciences, Notices of the American Mathematical Society 72 (9), October 2025. ↩︎
  3. Ilka Agricola, Lynn Heller, Wil Schilders, Moritz Schubotz, Peter Taylor and Luis Vega, How to Fight Fraudulent Publishing in the Mathematical Sciences: Joint Recommendations of the IMU and the ICIAM, arXiv:2509.09877, 2025. ↩︎
  4. Nandita Quaderi, 2024 Journal Citation Reports: Changes in Journal Impact Factor category rankings to enhance transparency and inclusivity, Clarivate Academia & Government Blog, 16 February 2024. ↩︎

Received 2 November 2026.

Comments are moderated. Read our comment policy.

Add to the discussion

New posts by email.

Prefer a feed reader? Subscribe by RSS.

Also on Mathstodon.

Latest comments across the site.

  1. You don’t need to “be stuck trying to understand it”. You can just ignore them, as Aaron Stump suggested, “just...